The couple aims to create a family home amidst community concerns and objections.
Topics covered
In a surprising turn of events, the planning application submitted by fashion designer Stella McCartney and her husband, Alasdhair Willis, has ignited a wave of controversy across the UK. The couple’s desire to build a family home at Commando Rock, located on the picturesque Moidart Peninsula, has drawn both local and national attention, with objections stemming from various corners of the country.
Community concerns and objections
Many objectors, some of whom reside far from the local area, have raised concerns that the proposed residence could become a “holiday getaway,” potentially disrupting the serene landscape of the region. Others have made disparaging remarks, labeling the couple as “white settlers” and questioning their intentions.
However, Willis is adamant that their goal is to create a permanent family home, emphasizing their deep connection to the area.
A commitment to the community
During an exclusive interview with The Press and Journal, Willis expressed his determination to address the concerns raised by the community. He described Commando Rock as a place where he and McCartney feel at home, despite the backlash they have faced. “This is where we want to be. It is not a whim; this has been our life plan,” he stated, highlighting their long-standing affection for the region.
Addressing environmental and architectural concerns
Among the objections are worries about the architectural style of the proposed home, which some believe does not align with the traditional aesthetics of the Lochailort area. Critics have also pointed out that the new plans position the house further forward than the original design, increasing its visibility from the bay. In response, Willis insists that the new design will harmonize with the landscape, stating, “We want a house that is in tune with the environment, not working against it.” He also reassured the community that an independent otter impact survey is underway to address wildlife concerns.
Historical context and future plans
The land on which the couple intends to build has a history of development, with previous planning permission granted for a different structure. Willis noted that the foundations for the earlier design were laid over two decades ago, and the couple’s current proposal aims to create a home that blends seamlessly into the natural surroundings. “We are fortunate to have been able to buy this land and to be able to come and live here. It is the most incredible place,” he remarked.
Public response and next steps
As the planning process unfolds, the couple has received a mixed response from the public, with only a handful of supportive comments among the 68 submissions received. The couple remains committed to engaging with local planners and addressing any legitimate concerns raised by the community. Willis concluded, “We want to work with them to find solutions for the concerns that people have raised.” As they navigate this challenging process, McCartney and Willis hope to establish a lasting presence in a place they cherish deeply.
